Two discussions Monofia Hotel Shebeen for my PhD under the supervision of Mr. D / Shabayek holiday, the first all-Badi in hair Bashar ibn Burd to allow student Mahmoud Ezzat Turi and participated in the discussion. D / praise Anas presence and D / Holiday Balba, and the other entitled: dialogue in the Hadith, the student: Mohammed Sharaf, and participated in the discussion. D / Mohammed Hassan Abdullah and D / holiday Balba, and got the student to estimate the first honors after making adjustments, and the student to second class honors after making adjustments as well.